The Unbelievable True Story of the Two Brady Feigls

This week’s story is one of those moments where reality out-coincides fiction.

Two professional baseball pitchers, both tall (6′4″), both red-haired, both bearded, both wearing glasses, and each named Brady Feigl, discovered they shared far more than just a name.

And they found out in the climactic corridor of coincidence: a doctor’s office.

Let’s dig in…

The odd convergence

In 2015, Pitcher Brady Feigl checked into an appointment for surgery on his throwing elbow (the common “Tommy John” kind for pitchers).

The next thing he knew, someone in the office asked him: “When are you arriving tomorrow for surgery?” He paused. “What? I just had it six months ago.”

Confusion followed. He learned that the clinic had him confused with another Brady Feigl, a guy who looked uncannily like him, had the same job, and was scheduled for the same surgeon.

Turns out: the second Brady Feigl was a fellow minor-league pitcher, with nearly identical physical features, same first name, same position, and yes, same elbow surgery, same surgeon even! How strange is that???

It was only after the medical mix-up that the two met, compared notes, and eventually took a DNA test (spoiler: they’re not related). Even so, the resemblance and synchronicity are impossible to ignore.

What makes this such an incredible “Happy Accident”

Here’s why this story fits our Happy Accident theme so neatly: it’s an accidental collision of identity, expectation and opportunity.

Neither Brady was looking for the other. Neither expected this moment of mirror-self surprise. Yet something about the intersection of names, professions and life events triggered the reveal.

• Recognition happens in odd places. They didn’t meet at a social event or by design, they discovered each other because of a scheduling error in a clinic.

• Surprises often lie beneath the surface. On paper the two athletes might’ve looked like separate stories. But the deeper you look, the more the overlap emerges: same name, same sport, same surgeon, same injury.

• Connection isn’t always planned, but it's powerful. Neither Brady sought out a doppelganger; fate did. But once aware, the story they share becomes richer because of the coincidence, not in spite of it.

What you can take away this week

Think of your own field, your own life. What have you overlooked because it felt too ordinary? What chance pairing, mismatched identifier or “someone like me” moment do you keep ignoring? Maybe there’s another you out there, or maybe there’s another version of your idea that just needs the right mirror to reflect it.

Ask yourself these questions:

• Are there two threads I’m running that might be the same story in disguise?

• Is there a goal, a role, a path I’m following that overlaps with someone else (even unknowingly)?

• What mistake (like a scheduling error) could reveal a symmetry I haven’t noticed yet?

Because sometimes life doesn’t announce big changes. It tips you off with a strange mix-up. A mirror image you never expected. And that’s when you’re attention is quietly drawn to an unexplored path.

So this week, keep your eyes open for the “Who’s this other me?” moments. They might begin with a harmless confusion. But they could lead to something far more meaningful.

Tips and Strategies for Solopreneurs

How to Network Like a Pro

Find me on X, LinkedIn, Threads, or Book a 1:1 Call

Whenever you’re ready, here are 3 ways I can help you: